The answer: It’s not recommended. See, protein shakes, by their very nature, are packed with protein—but not much else. And one-ingredient meals are just never a good idea, says Gans.
Table of Contents
Which meal should I replace with a shake?
A meal replacement shake is designed to replace your breakfast, lunch, or dinner. They are often filled with nutrients but have fewer calories than you would eat during a meal. Look for a meal replacement shake high in protein if you want help managing your appetite.
Is it OK to replace a meal with a protein shake?
Can protein shakes be used as meal replacements? No, protein shakes cannot be used as meal replacements. Protein shakes lack the variety of vitamins and minerals required to make them a valuable food source. Protein shakes supplement the amino acid intake of a person.
Is it better to replace lunch or dinner with a protein shake?
An article published in the Journal of Dietary Supplements in May 2018 confirms that getting your protein from whole foods is superior. When you replace just one meal per day with a shake and consume whole foods at other meals, you’re more likely to get all the nutrients you need for a healthy, energized body.
How many meals can I replace with a protein shake?
However, the most balanced protein shake diets include protein shakes as part of a diet that is rich in other food sources. For instance, the diet might recommend replacing one or two meals with a protein shake, then eating one or two different meals that also provide nutritional benefits, as well as snacks.
Can you lose weight by replacing 2 meals with protein shakes?
Meal replacement shakes can help you feel full while consuming fewer calories ( 5 ). Several studies suggest that replacing one or two meals per day with a healthy meal replacement shake may speed up weight loss ( 6 , 7 , 8 ).
What drink can replace a meal?
- Ample Original Complete Meal Shake.
- Soylent Original Plant Protein Meal Replacement Shake.
- Keto Function Keto+ Shake.
- ALOHA Organic Plant-Based Protein Bars.
- OWYN Complete Nutrition Shake.
- Ripple Nutrition Protein Shake.
- GoMacro MacroBars (Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip)
Do protein shakes make you gain weight?
Adding protein shakes to your daily diet can help you gain weight very easily and efficiently. The added calories, proteins and nutrients will help you to grow muscle and put on weight.
Do protein shakes make you fat?
Truth be told: You can overdo it on any type of food. If you eat more than what your body needs, you are likely to gain weight. But, no, protein shakes as part of a healthy, balanced diet will not make you fat on their own.
Is it better to have a protein shake for breakfast or dinner?
The bottom line. Drinking a protein shake for breakfast can be a quick and convenient way to squeeze more nutrients into your diet and increase your protein intake. Protein shakes can also be an effective tool to support weight loss and enhance muscle growth.
Can I replace breakfast with protein shake?
Replacing your morning meal with a protein shake is a great idea if you’re trying to drop extra pounds. Most protein powders recommend using one scoop of protein per shake, which is usually equal to about 25 grams of protein.
Why you shouldn’t drink protein shakes?
It may be high in added sugars and calories. Some protein powders have little added sugar, and others have a lot (as much as 23 grams per scoop). Some protein powders wind up turning a glass of milk into a drink with more than 1,200 calories. The risk: weight gain and an unhealthy spike in blood sugar.
What happens if you only drink protein shakes for a month?
You could gain weight They simply cannot provide enough well-rounded nutrition to be your only source of fuel. Furthermore, overdoing it on the protein shakes can lead to weight gain because they tend to be higher in calories, according to Livestrong).
Can I lose weight just drinking protein shakes?
Protein shakes are good for weight loss because they are satiating and may boost metabolism. Replace a meal, like dinner, with a low-calorie, no added sugar protein shake to lose weight. It’s best to make your own protein shake with fruits, nut butter, and a sugar-free protein powder.
What happens if I only drink protein shakes for a week?
If you’re on a protein shake diet for a week or five days, it’s probably not long enough to cause any real harm, but there’s a good chance you’ll regain any weight you’ve lost when you start eating whole foods again.
Why am I gaining weight on meal replacement shakes?
You’re Adding Too Much to It The thing is, everything you add to a meal replacement shake is going to add calories as well as flavor. If you’ve gotten into the habit of adding stuff, even healthy stuff, to your shakes, you may be increasing your caloric intake more than you realize.
What happens if you drink protein shakes without working out?
In short, if you drink a protein shake on a rest day, or a day when you’re doing less than you might usually do, there’s no need to worry about any adverse effects. However, if you’re drinking high protein shakes on their own and not to supplement your protein intake when working out, this could cause weight gain.
How often should you drink protein shakes to lose weight?
If you have a significant amount of weight to lose, scientific studies have shown you might be most successful if you have two or more shakes daily and reduce calories in the rest of your diet.
When should you drink protein shakes?
Ideally, you should consume a protein shake within 30 minutes of completing your workout. This ensures that your muscles are getting the nutrients they need to recover and grow. If you’re not working out, you can still have a protein shake, but it’s best to consume it between meals.
How much protein do I need a day?
How much protein do you need? Anywhere from 10% to 35% of your calories should come from protein. So if your needs are 2,000 calories, that’s 200–700 calories from protein, or 50–175 grams. The recommended dietary allowance to prevent deficiency for an average sedentary adult is 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight.
What is the best food for high protein?
- Lean Beef. = 22 grams protein per 3-ounce serving of 93%-lean ground beef.
- Chicken. = 27 grams protein per 3-ounce serving of skinless chicken breast.
- Salmon. = 19 grams protein per 3-ounce serving.
- Eggs. = 6 grams protein per 1 large egg.
- Peanut Butter.
- Pasta.
- Cottage Cheese.
- Lentils.
Which protein is best for weight loss?
Whey protein has been linked to some impressive benefits, including greater weight loss, improved satiety and better body composition ( 32 , 33 ).
Should I have milk with my protein shake?
When building mass and muscle, mixing your protein with milk will yield better results. For lean builders, trimmers and toners, water is the way to go. It comes down to nutrition, as that’s exactly why you are drinking protein shakes in the first place.
Are 2 protein shakes a day too much?
If you work out regularly and you’re trying to build muscle, two protein shakes per day is plenty. And if you’re not that active, you likely don’t need more than one protein shake per day.
Can I eat eggs and drink a protein shake?
Adding raw egg to a protein shake increases its protein content, but you would be further ahead by eating a hard-boiled egg with the shake instead. To reduce your risk of Salmonella infection, select organic, free-range eggs and consume them while they are fresh.